Celtic
Honest Mistakes – There’s Been An Intervention
Two weeks of fixtures for the high price you pay to access all the data on this site – insert a sarky emoji here.
This takes us up to the Scottish Cup matches and both sides have played 29 SPFL matches.
The impact of big calls being incorrect can then be evaluated using the framework outlined here -> Honest Mistakes in the SPFL.
28/02/24 Celtic vs Dundee
Incident 1
Referee | Matthew McDermid |
Game Minute | 76th |
Score At Time | 7-0 |
Incident | Robertson fouls Johnston |
Outcome | Foul to Celtic and 2nd YC to Robertson |
Evidence | BBC iPlayer – Sportscene – Premiership Highlights 2023/24: 28/02/2024
At 36:38 |
28/02/24 Kilmarnock vs The Rangers
Incident 1
Referee | David Dickinson |
Game Minute | 11th |
Score At Time | 0-0 |
Incident | Lundstram blocks a cross into the box |
Outcome | Penalty awarded to Kilmarnock for hand ball |
Evidence | BBC iPlayer – Sportscene – Premiership Highlights 2023/24: 28/02/2024 At 17:17 |
Yorkshire Whistler Verdict | Initial on field decision: Handball awarded and penalty given to Kilmarnock
Lundstram jumps and spins with his left arm to block the cross and the ball does seem to hit him on the elbow. Even though his arm isn’t significantly extended outwards, there does appear to be an element of unnatural positioning of the arm and body shape as a result of this spin. Once the ball hits his elbow his arm, it then seems to extend out even further, although this happens immediately after the ball hits the elbow. Given the unnecessary body spin and loose left arm as a result, I would support the call to award this as a handball offence. |
Expected Points
Outcome |
No impact |
Incident 2
Referee | David Dickinson |
Game Minute | 39th |
Score At Time | 1-0 |
Incident | Polworth tries to run onto a Diomande back pass |
Outcome | No decision |
Evidence | BBC iPlayer – Sportscene – Premiership Highlights 2023/24: 28/02/2024
At 19:16 |
Yorkshire Whistler Verdict | Initial on-field decision: No foul committed
As Polworth attempts to latch onto an under-hit back pass, he claims that Diomande pulls him back as he runs passed the Rangers man. I would categorise this as justifiable contact from the defender as he puts his arm out for only a split second and there is no obvious pulling-back motion committed. His left arm comes out slightly to block Polworth, but I would say this just about sits within what is deemed to be expected player-on-player contact. Verdict: CORRECT DECISION |
Expected Points
Outcome |
No impact |
Incident 3
Referee | David Dickinson |
Game Minute | 79th |
Score At Time | 1-2 |
Incident | Donnelly goes down in the box |
Outcome | No decision |
Evidence | BBC iPlayer – Sportscene – Premiership Highlights 2023/24: 28/02/2024
At 22:43 |
Yorkshire Whistler Verdict | Initial on field decision: No foul committed
Donnelly & a Rangers defender both compete to get to the ball first, it looks like the Rangers defender is just behind Donnelly who feels contact and goes down in the box looking for a penalty. I do not see the defender make any obvious attempt to tackle or challenge Donnelly and certainly nothing that warrants a clear infringement. Again, I feel we are in the realm of expected, justifiable contact to compete for the ball and space around the ball. No foul was committed. |
Expected Points
Outcome |
No impact |
Incident 4
Referee | David Dickinson |
Game Minute | 87th |
Score At Time | 1-2 |
Incident | Ball hits Findlay in the box |
Outcome | No decision |
Evidence | BBC iPlayer – Sportscene – Premiership Highlights 2023/24: 28/02/2024
At 23:21 |
Yorkshire Whistler Verdict | Initial on field decision: No foul committed
Dessers and Findlay both go to play the ball and the ball bounces up and clearly catches the defender accidentally on the hand. However, this contact occurs due to the ball bouncing up which gives Findlay virtually zero reaction time. His arms appear to be in a very natural position as he challenges the Rangers forward and I would have been bewildered if anyone had deemed this to be a handball offence. Verdict: CORRECT DECISION |
Expected Points
Outcome |
No impact |
02/03/24 The Rangers vs Motherwell
Incident 1
Referee | Alan Muir |
Game Minute | 35th |
Score At Time | 0-1 |
Incident | Carey and McCausland challenge for the ball |
Outcome | Foul to TRFC |
Evidence | https://x.com/ScotlandSky/status/1764625959561396567?s=20
At 0:43 |
Yorkshire Whistler Verdict | Initial on field decision: Foul to Rangers, no further action after review.
Carey and McCausland both compete for a loose ball and Carey fully commits to a sliding tackle, which sees McCausland fall to the floor injured in the aftermath. At full speed, my instinct was a good strong challenge that saw Carey robustly win the ball first, before his follow-through made contact with the Rangers man. Upon watching the replays, I stick by my opinion that this is a strong but fair challenge. I suspect that if McCausland fully commits to the 50/50 challenge he is ironically, less likely to injury himself. It appears that at the last second, he changes his mind to commit to the tackle (in old school terminology – he doesn’t fancy it) and turns his body and dangles his right leg out. Carey’s follow through after winning the ball, then catches this loose leg of McCausland, which wouldn’t have happened if the Rangers had made a stronger effort to tackle Carey. I find it hard to look to penalise Carey in this particular scenario and actually disagree with the on-field decision to award a free kick in the first place. Verdict: INCORRECT DECISION. No foul was committed. |
Expected Points
Outcome |
No impact |
Incident 2
Referee | Alan Muir |
Game Minute | 56th |
Score At Time | 0-1 |
Incident | Silva goes over in the box |
Outcome | No decision; Penalty to TRFC upon VAR review |
Evidence | BBC iPlayer – Sportscene – Premiership Highlights 2023/24: 02/03/2024
At 6:10 |
Yorkshire Whistler Verdict | Initial on field decision: No foul but after VAR review, penalty awarded to Rangers
Silva breaks into the box and under the challenge from Casey & O’Donnell goes to ground. I suspect the referee is unsighted to O’Connell’s challenge and feels body on body block from Casey, on its own, is not enough to warrant the foul. However, on review, you can see that Silva plays the ball first before O’Donnell’s sliding tackle catches him & not the ball, a split second before Casey collides with the Rangers forward. For me, the sliding defender makes no contact on the ball but does catch Silva and a foul is committed. Verdict: CORRECT DECISION to award the penalty |
Expected Points
Outcome |
No impact |
03/03/24 Hearts vs Celtic
Incident 1
Referee | Don Robertson |
Game Minute | 11th |
Score At Time | 0-0 |
Incident | Yang goes down in the box |
Outcome | Penalty to Celtic |
Evidence | BBC iPlayer – Sportscene – Premiership Highlights 2023/24: Hearts v Celtic
At 3:00 |
Yorkshire Whistler Verdict | Initial on field decision: Penalty awarded to Celtic
Yang looks to get in behind the Hearts defender Cochrane and they come together shortly after. Yang goes to ground and a penalty is awarded to Celtic. At full speed my initial reaction was that there was expected contact between defender & attacker and no clear foul had been committed by the Hearts man. I thought Yang stepped across the Hearts defender and initiated the contact by impacting Cochrane’s running stride. However, on reviewing the replay, it does appear that Cochrane does actually stretch to play the ball and as Yang has got his body in front of Cochrane, the defender’s stretch makes no contact on the ball but clips Yang’s right foot. On that basis, I’m happy to support the on-field decision to award the penalty. Verdict: CORRECT DECISION to award the penalty |
Expected Points
Outcome |
No impact |
Incident 2
Referee | Don Robertson |
Game Minute | 16th |
Score At Time | 0-0 |
Incident | Yang and Cochrane challenge for the ball |
Outcome | Foul to Hearts and YC to Yang upgraded to RC after VAR review |
Evidence | BBC iPlayer – Sportscene – Premiership Highlights 2023/24: Hearts v Celtic
At 4:09 |
Yorkshire Whistler Verdict | Initial on field decision: Foul to Hearts and Yang cautioned. After VAR review this is upgraded to a red card to Yang.
Yang attempts to control a high ball with his foot as Cochrane attempts to head the ball. At full speed it appears that Cochrane wins the ball first before Yang’s studs catch him in the face. I do have some sympathy for Yang as he doesn’t seem to be aware of how close Cochrane’s head is as he attempts to play the ball. However, Yang’s right foot is fully extended at neck height as Cochrane arrives to head the ball. Once Yang makes contact with Cochrane’s head at this height, I would say this falls in the territory of serious foul play and endangering a player’s safety. On balance, I would support the decision to upgrade the foul to a sending-off offence. Verdict: CORRECT DECISION to issue the red card for the offence. |
Expected Points
Outcome |
No impact |
Incident 3
Referee | Don Robertson |
Game Minute | 43rd |
Score At Time | 0-0 |
Incident | Johnston clears the ball and it hits Iwata |
Outcome | No decision; Penalty to Hearts upon VAR review |
Evidence | BBC iPlayer – Sportscene – Premiership Highlights 2023/24: Hearts v Celtic
At 8:12 |
Yorkshire Whistler Verdict | Initial on field decision: No foul, but then after VAR review, penalty awarded to Hearts for a hand ball offence.
Harsh decision to deem the accidental hand ball as a punishable hand ball offence. Even though Iwata’s arm is slightly extended, he is in a jumping motion and gets barged mid-flight by his teammate. This then causes his arm to involuntarily extend in mid-jump. I feel this is a justifiable body movement specific to that situation. As such I disagree with the penalty decision and feel the referee’s initial ‘no foul’ decision should have been the expected outcome. Verdict: INCORRECT DECISION. No foul handball offence was committed. |
Expected Points
Outcome |
Celtic -0.54 xPts |
Summary
My thanks as always to the Yorkshire Whistler.
In the main another good week for the officials.
However, John Beaton’s decision to ask Don Robertson to overturn a non-decision to a handball penalty for Hearts was not only inexplicable but potentially material to a very tight and lucrative title race. Given the game state and the fact Hearts were struggling to break down a 10-man Celtic in front of an increasingly agitated home crowd, it carried additional weight.
In terms of the overall position:
The Rangers have 0.53 MORE points and Celtic 0.83 less than expected due to the impact of Honest Mistakes. The Rangers are benefiting by an estimated 1.36 xPts due to the impact of honest mistakes.
The Rangers lead by two points after 29 matches.
-
North queenlands cowboys7 months ago
XXXX things you need to know: Round 6 v Eels
-
Blog4 months ago
Rangers’ goalkeeper officially ends his loan exit today.
-
Celtic7 months ago
Celtic fan dies ahead of Parkhead clash as tributes paid to ‘fierce’ club stalwart
-
Celtic7 months ago
Boyd brands Rodgers SFA ban as ‘weak’ and says Celtic statement made him laugh
-
Rangers5 months ago
Rangers to shell out £7.7m to seal new deal
-
Celtic7 months ago
Exclusive! Brendan Rodgers’ blast is the SFA’message’ for John Beaton Rangers vs. Celtic curveball.
-
Blog4 months ago
‘He’ll go to…’: A former teammate talks about what a £5 million Rangers target told him about the summer transfer period
-
Blog4 months ago
The American consortium’s plan to take over the Rangers for a lot of money was stopped by fear of the “most hated person in the UK”