Connect with us

Blog

Pat Bonner raises doubts over whether Celtic’s players are good enough.

Published

on

Celtic’s disappointing 2-0 defeat at Falkirk has prompted serious criticism from former players Chris Sutton and Pat Bonner, with concerns raised about the quality of the squad, the team’s tactical direction and the strength available from the bench. Bonner believes there are major doubts over whether some of the current players are good enough to represent Celtic, while Sutton has described a side that appears short of a clear plan and is struggling in several areas.

The result at Falkirk Stadium was particularly frustrating for Celtic because the hosts were able to defend effectively and create greater attacking threat. Scott Bain, the former Celtic goalkeeper now playing for Falkirk, produced an outstanding performance to keep the visitors out. Bonner praised Bain’s contribution, saying he had counted eight saves, and felt Falkirk fully deserved the victory.

1st November 2026; Falkirk Stadium, Scottish Premiership, Falkirk versus Celtic; Dejected Celtic players applaud the fans. Photo Vagelis Georgariou

9th August 2026; Rugby Park, Kilmarnock, Scottish Premiership, Kilmarnock versus Celtic; Luke McCowan of Celtic celebrates with James Forrest of Celtic and Kieran Tierney of Celtic after he shoots and scores in the 75th minute to make it 5-1 to Celtic. Photo by Vagelis Georgariou

Sutton questions Celtic’s structure

Sutton was highly critical of the team’s overall organisation and the decisions surrounding its formation. He argued that Celtic’s midfield lacks the athleticism and physical strength needed to make the system work, particularly if the manager wants to use two strikers together.

11th October 2026; Fir Park, Motherwell, North Lanarkshire, Scotland; Scottish Premiership Football, Motherwell versus Celtic; Sebastian Tounekti of Celtic

The former Celtic forward questioned why the club had recruited two strikers if they could not be selected alongside one another. In his view, a 4-4-2 formation is not a realistic option because the midfielders do not have the physical qualities required to operate effectively in that shape. He also noted that Martin O’Neill does not want to use a back three, leaving questions about how the squad is supposed to function.

1st November 2026; Falkirk Stadium, Scottish Premiership, Falkirk versus Celtic; Sam Johnstone of Celtic. Photo Vagelis Georgariou

Sutton also criticised the way Celtic defend and build attacks. He singled out Liam Scales, suggesting the defender sometimes carries the ball forward as though he were the great Italian centre-back Franco Baresi, despite not having the same ability. His wider point was that Celtic are lacking the right balance and qualities across the team.

He believes O’Neill must make his preferred approach clear and then remain committed to it. Sutton said the uncertainty surrounding team selection and tactics leaves supporters wondering what kind of Celtic side will appear from one match to the next. He described the situation as a lottery, with no obvious consistency in the manager’s choices.

Sutton went further by claiming that both the club and the team are moving backwards. He said Celtic are not functioning properly at present and that it is difficult to understand how they are meant to play. In his assessment, the side looks improvised, with weaknesses throughout the squad and no convincing strategy. He questioned where the plan is and what the overall direction should be.

Midfield and goalkeeping concerns

1st November 2026; Falkirk Stadium, Scottish Premiership Falkirk versus Celtic; Scott Bain of Falkirk celebrates with Lewis Neilson of Falkirk after making a save. Photo Vagelis Georgariou

Sutton also highlighted the vulnerability of Celtic’s midfield, although he stressed that the problems are not restricted to that department. He raised concerns about the goalkeeping situation, saying it was a mess. Sam Johnstone, in particular, did not inspire or excite him, and Sutton suggested that the goalkeeper was likely to remain in a safe position.

Bonner praises Falkirk and raises Celtic doubts

1st November 2026; Falkirk Stadium, Scottish Premiership Falkirk versus Celtic; Falkirk manager John McGlynn protests a decision. Photo Vagelis Georgariou

Bonner, speaking on BBC Sportsound, offered strong praise for Falkirk’s defensive work and the performance of Bain. He felt the home side showed far more penetration than Celtic, who moved the ball from one side to the other without creating enough danger.

The former Celtic goalkeeper described Falkirk’s display as terrific and singled out Bain as unbelievable. He was impressed by the number of saves the goalkeeper made and concluded that the hosts were worthy winners. Bonner also praised Falkirk’s young squad and the work of manager John McGlynn.

McGlynn had been required to rebuild his team during the summer, making 17 signings. Despite the scale of those changes, Bonner noted that Falkirk looked like a well-drilled unit. Their organisation and understanding were evident against Celtic, and the performance suggested that the manager had brought the new players together effectively.

1st November 2026; Falkirk Stadium; Scottish Premiership, Falkirk versus Celtic; Celtic coaches inn the dugout. Photo Vagelis Georgariou

Bonner’s most pointed assessment concerned the standard of Celtic’s squad. While recognising Falkirk’s quality, he questioned whether some of the players currently at Celtic are good enough for a club with such expectations. His comments reflect concerns about the level of quality available to O’Neill, particularly when the team needs substitutes capable of making a difference.

Celtic remain top despite the setback

The defeat came despite Celtic still occupying first place in the league table. They remain four points ahead of Rangers, although their rivals have a game in hand. O’Neill referred to the league position during his media interviews after the match, pointing out that Celtic are still top.

However, being at the summit has not prevented supporters from expressing concern about the team’s performances. Some believe the problems have been visible for some time and that the loss at Falkirk was not an isolated surprise, but the outcome of weaknesses that had been building.

One assessment of the situation described the defeat as an accident waiting to happen. Although Celtic’s league position remains positive, there is a feeling that the team is among the poorest coached sides in the division. The contrast between their position in the table and the quality of their football has become a major talking point.

O’Neill now faces questions about how he intends to improve the side and whether the current group has enough quality to meet the club’s ambitions. Sutton wants a clearer tactical identity, while Bonner has raised doubts about the players themselves. The concerns are connected: a more consistent system may help, but Celtic also need individuals who can carry it out.

The post-match reaction has therefore focused on more than the scoreline. Falkirk’s organisation, Bain’s saves and McGlynn’s work were all praised, while Celtic’s midfield, goalkeeping, attacking threat, substitutions and overall direction came under scrutiny. The challenge for O’Neill is to respond to those criticisms and show that his team can deliver performances worthy of its standing.

Celtic may still lead the table, but the defeat has intensified questions about the squad’s quality and the manager’s plan.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending