Why Celtic Cannot Simply Go All-In During the January Transfer Window

At the Celtic AGM held at Parkhead in November, emotions were already running high before Ross Desmond had even begun to speak. As boos and heckles echoed around the Kerrydale Suite, the son of major shareholder Dermot Desmond attempted to offer an explanation for why the Scottish champions operate the way they do in the transfer market. His words, however, were largely drowned out by frustration from shareholders who felt the club’s ambition no longer matched its financial power.

Earlier in the meeting, chairman Peter Lawwell had been forced to leave proceedings altogether as disorder escalated. By the time Ross Desmond addressed the room, the atmosphere was already hostile. Nevertheless, he tried to articulate why modern football economics make squad building far more complicated than many supporters appreciate.

Desmond stressed that Celtic’s board prioritises long-term financial stability over short-term risk. According to him, accusations that the club is hoarding money or prioritising profit over success stem from a misunderstanding of how elite football now operates. He argued that the landscape of European football has changed dramatically since Celtic’s last sustained run at the top level in the early 2000s, creating financial gaps that continue to widen.

While acknowledging that clubs should still aim to outperform their financial standing, Desmond warned that reckless spending could endanger the club’s foundations. If a gamble fails, he said, the consequences could be severe and long-lasting.

Those words landed badly with many supporters. The disappointment of a poor summer transfer window was still fresh, as was the humiliation of losing a Champions League play-off to Kairat, a result that denied Celtic a lucrative place in Europe’s elite competition. Fans struggled to reconcile caution with the club’s recent financial disclosures, which showed cash reserves of more than £77 million.

New Celtic loan signing Julian Araujo of Bournemouth challenges Anthony Ralston for the ball during training at Lennoxtown (Image: Stuart Wallace / Shutterstock)

Many questioned why a club that had narrowly lost to Bayern Munich in European competition the previous season could enter such a decisive tie so underprepared. The absence of natural replacements for Kyogo Furuhashi and Nicolas Kuhn, coupled with the financial windfall Celtic had accumulated, made restraint difficult to accept.

Yet beneath the anger, a broader question remained: was Ross Desmond making a point that simply went unheard? Has modern football reached a stage where clubs like Celtic face greater challenges than ever before when trying to strengthen? And could aggressive spending now create serious problems later?

The Regulatory Reality Celtic Must Navigate

To understand the situation more clearly, it helps to consider the views of Dr Dan Plumley, a senior lecturer in sport business management at Sheffield Hallam University and a specialist in football finance. Plumley has studied how clubs outside Europe’s elite navigate structural disadvantages through smart recruitment and innovative planning. However, he also understands why Celtic must tread carefully.

UEFA’s introduction of the squad cost ratio has fundamentally reshaped spending limits across European football. Under these rules, a club’s total squad costs — including player wages, managerial salaries, transfer amortisation, and agent fees — cannot exceed 70 percent of turnover.

Plumley explains that every financial commitment in the transfer market counts toward that limit. While Celtic are not currently close to breaching the threshold, they cannot afford to push spending too aggressively. Any violation would bring sanctions, fines, and reputational damage, especially once European qualification is secured.

Several high-profile clubs across Europe have already felt the consequences of these rules, with the likes of Aston Villa, Chelsea, Lyon, and Barcelona all receiving substantial penalties. Celtic, Plumley says, are acutely aware of that risk.

This reality places the club in a difficult position. Supporters demand investment, particularly when results falter, but the regulatory environment restricts how freely money can be spent. In that context, the idea that Celtic can simply “attack the transfer market hard” becomes unrealistic.

Sebastian Tounekti during a Celtic training session at Lennoxtown (Image: Andrew Milligan)

Cash Reserves Are Not a Blank Cheque

One of the most common arguments from supporters centres on Celtic’s cash balance. However, Plumley cautions against viewing that figure as disposable income.

Celtic’s turnover stands at approximately £143 million. Their most recent accounts show total wages of £75 million, with player wages alone estimated to exceed £50 million. When these numbers are assessed against UEFA’s limits, the room for manoeuvre is far smaller than it might appear.

The £77 million held in reserve serves multiple purposes beyond transfers. It supports operational costs, buffers against financial shocks, and fluctuates throughout the financial year. It is not, as Plumley puts it, a pot of money waiting to be emptied on new signings.

Celtic Have Spent — And Spent Big

Contrary to the perception that Celtic refuse to invest, the club has committed significant sums in recent seasons. Ahead of the 2022/23 campaign, they paid substantial fees for Alexandro Bernabei, Cameron Carter-Vickers, and Jota. The following year, under Brendan Rodgers, close to £20 million was spent on multiple additions, including Odin Thiago Holm and Maik Nawrocki.

Last season marked an unprecedented outlay. Celtic spent around £40 million, bringing in players such as Adam Idah, Arne Engels, Auston Trusty, and Jota once again. Those investments were made with the security of guaranteed Champions League participation, thanks to Scotland’s coefficient at the time.

Jota celebrates scoring a goal for Celtic at Parkhead earlier this year (Image: Andrew Milligan)

That safety net no longer exists. With qualification now dependent on navigating play-offs, the board has been reluctant to commit heavily before European revenue is secured. Previous failures in qualifiers have left lasting scars, reinforcing a cautious approach.

Profit, Perception, and Frustration

During the summer, Celtic spent £13 million on new players but generated more through sales, including the departures of Kuhn and Idah. From a financial perspective, the club turned a healthy trading profit.

That did little to appease supporters, particularly after Celtic earned nearly £40 million from Champions League participation in the 2024/25 season. Critics argued that money sitting idle serves little purpose if the team is not strong enough to achieve its objectives.

Plumley, however, understands the hesitation. He points out that while Celtic will always be capable of entering the transfer market, it does not mean they can compete freely for elite talent. Qualification for the Champions League remains the single biggest factor that can change their financial outlook, but even that comes with risk.

Spending heavily before qualification could push squad costs beyond sustainable levels if European income fails to materialise. Conversely, holding back may weaken the team’s chances of qualifying at all. It is a delicate balancing act with no easy solution.

A Changing European Landscape

Beyond regulations, football itself has evolved. Commercialisation, global branding, overseas tours, and multi-club ownership models have reshaped recruitment and competition. Many elite clubs now benefit from interconnected networks that funnel talent efficiently across leagues.

Broadcast deals also entrench inequality. The Premier League’s television rights are locked in until 2029, while Champions League agreements extend well into the future. The same clubs are likely to dominate European competitions for years to come.

Major Celtic shareholder Dermot Desmond (Image: Shutterstock)

Even when Celtic qualify for the Champions League, they enter at a disadvantage. Simply spending more does not close the gap.

Lessons From Elsewhere

Some clubs have found alternative paths to success. Norwegian side Bodo/Glimt, despite operating with a turnover of just €30 million, have reached the latter stages of multiple European competitions in recent years.

Plumley believes such examples demonstrate the value of identity-driven recruitment models. Clubs must ask fundamental questions about who they are, where they source players from, and how they create value.

Selling more than you buy can positively impact squad cost calculations, while focusing on younger players with resale potential offers sustainability. These approaches are challenging but viable.

He also points to Hearts as a domestic example. With a turnover significantly lower than Celtic’s, Hearts’ innovative ownership structure and data-led recruitment show how clubs can punch above their weight.

Conclusion

Celtic’s financial strength is undeniable, but so too are the constraints they operate under. Regulatory limits, uncertain European qualification, and a transformed football economy mean reckless spending is no longer an option.

While supporters crave ambition and immediate success, the club’s hierarchy faces decisions with consequences that stretch years into the future. Attacking the transfer market without restraint may satisfy short-term demands, but it risks undermining the stability that has sustained Celtic for decades.

In modern football, prudence is not always popular — but it may be necessary.

Celtic backed to land the best striker in Scotland

Celtic have been urged to move decisively in the January transfer window, with growing pressure on the club to secure a reliable source of goals as key fixtures loom. Ongoing uncertainty surrounding Kyogo Furuhashi’s situation has prompted the Hoops to widen their search, ensuring they are not left exposed if a swift resolution cannot be reached.

Soccer Football – Championship – Leicester City v Birmingham City – King Power Stadium, Leicester, Britain – August 29, 2025 Birmingham City’s Kyogo Furuhashi reacts Action Images/Andrew Boyers EDITORIAL USE ONLY. NO USE WITH UNAUTHORIZED AUDIO, VIDEO, DATA, FIXTURE LISTS, CLUB/LEAGUE LOGOS OR ‘LIVE’ SERVICES. ONLINE IN-MATCH USE LIMITED TO 120 IMAGES, NO VIDEO EMULATION. NO USE IN BETTING, GAMES OR SINGLE CLUB/LEAGUE/PLAYER PUBLICATIONS. PLEASE CONTACT YOUR ACCOUNT REPRESENTATIVE FOR FURTHER DETAILS..

Soccer Football – Premier League – West Ham United v Fulham – London Stadium, London, Britain – December 27, 2025 West Ham United’s Callum Wilson looks dejected after the match Action Images via Reuters/Andrew Boyers EDITORIAL USE ONLY. NO USE WITH UNAUTHORIZED AUDIO, VIDEO, DATA, FIXTURE LISTS, CLUB/LEAGUE LOGOS OR ‘LIVE’ SERVICES. ONLINE IN-MATCH USE LIMITED TO 120 IMAGES, NO VIDEO EMULATION. NO USE IN BETTING, GAMES OR SINGLE CLUB/LEAGUE/PLAYER PUBLICATIONS. PLEASE CONTACT YOUR ACCOUNT REPRESENTATIVE FOR FURTHER DETAILS..

Soccer Football – Champions League – Group E – Celtic v Feyenoord – Celtic Park, Glasgow, Scotland, Britain – December 13, 2023 Feyenoord’s Justin Bijlow makes a save from Celtic’s Kyogo Furuhashi REUTERS/Russell Cheyne

Soccer Football – Premier League – AFC Bournemouth v West Ham United – Vitality Stadium, Bournemouth, Britain – November 22, 2025 West Ham United’s Callum Wilson celebrates scoring their second goal with Jean-Clair Todibo Action Images via Reuters/John Sibley EDITORIAL USE ONLY. NO USE WITH UNAUTHORIZED AUDIO, VIDEO, DATA, FIXTURE LISTS, CLUB/LEAGUE LOGOS OR ‘LIVE’ SERVICES. ONLINE IN-MATCH USE LIMITED TO 120 IMAGES, NO VIDEO EMULATION. NO USE IN BETTING, GAMES OR SINGLE CLUB/LEAGUE/PLAYER PUBLICATIONS. PLEASE CONTACT YOUR ACCOUNT REPRESENTATIVE FOR FURTHER DETAILS..

Soccer Football – Scottish League Cup Final – Hibernian v Celtic – Hampden Park, Glasgow, Scotland, Britain – December 19, 2021 Celtic’s Kyogo Furuhashi celebrates with the trophy after winning the league cup final REUTERS/Russell Cheyne

Soccer Football – Premier League – AFC Bournemouth v West Ham United – Vitality Stadium, Bournemouth, Britain – November 22, 2025 West Ham United’s Callum Wilson reacts Action Images via Reuters/John Sibley EDITORIAL USE ONLY. NO USE WITH UNAUTHORIZED AUDIO, VIDEO, DATA, FIXTURE LISTS, CLUB/LEAGUE LOGOS OR ‘LIVE’ SERVICES. ONLINE IN-MATCH USE LIMITED TO 120 IMAGES, NO VIDEO EMULATION. NO USE IN BETTING, GAMES OR SINGLE CLUB/LEAGUE/PLAYER PUBLICATIONS. PLEASE CONTACT YOUR ACCOUNT REPRESENTATIVE FOR FURTHER DETAILS..

Soccer Football – Scottish Premiership – Celtic v Rangers – Celtic Park, Glasgow, Scotland, Britain – September 1, 2024 Celtic’s Kyogo Furuhashi celebrates scoring their second goal with Alistair Johnston and Nicolas Gerrit Kuhn REUTERS/Russell Cheyne

Soccer Football – Premier League – West Ham United v Brighton & Hove Albion – London Stadium, London, Britain – December 30, 2025 West Ham United’s Callum Wilson in action with Brighton & Hove Albion’s Jan Paul van Hecke REUTERS/Tony O Brien EDITORIAL USE ONLY. NO USE WITH UNAUTHORIZED AUDIO, VIDEO, DATA, FIXTURE LISTS, CLUB/LEAGUE LOGOS OR ‘LIVE’ SERVICES. ONLINE IN-MATCH USE LIMITED TO 120 IMAGES, NO VIDEO EMULATION. NO USE IN BETTING, GAMES OR SINGLE CLUB/LEAGUE/PLAYER PUBLICATIONS. PLEASE CONTACT YOUR ACCOUNT REPRESENTATIVE FOR FURTHER DETAILS..

Soccer Football – Scottish Premiership – Rangers v Celtic – Ibrox, Glasgow, Scotland, Britain – January 2, 2025 Celtic’s Kyogo Furuhashi arrives at the stadium before the match REUTERS/Russell Cheyne

Soccer Football – Premier League – West Ham United v Brighton & Hove Albion – London Stadium, London, Britain – December 30, 2025 West Ham United’s Callum Wilson reacts REUTERS/Tony O Brien EDITORIAL USE ONLY. NO USE WITH UNAUTHORIZED AUDIO, VIDEO, DATA, FIXTURE LISTS, CLUB/LEAGUE LOGOS OR ‘LIVE’ SERVICES. ONLINE IN-MATCH USE LIMITED TO 120 IMAGES, NO VIDEO EMULATION. NO USE IN BETTING, GAMES OR SINGLE CLUB/LEAGUE/PLAYER PUBLICATIONS. PLEASE CONTACT YOUR ACCOUNT REPRESENTATIVE FOR FURTHER DETAILS..

With time working against them, Celtic are increasingly conscious of the risks of delay. Martin O’Neill, back in charge and tasked with steadying the ship, is keen to add firepower as quickly as possible. The congested fixture list and the intensity of the title race mean there is little margin for error, and the club is determined to avoid entering decisive matches without sufficient attacking options.

Against this backdrop, attention has turned to alternative short-term solutions that could offer immediate impact without committing the club to long-term financial or sporting risk. One name now firmly in the conversation is Callum Wilson, who is currently available as a free agent following his departure from West Ham United.

Wilson’s availability has caught the attention of several observers, but it is former Celtic defender Alan Stubbs who has most strongly advocated for the move. Stubbs believes the experienced striker would be an ideal fit for O’Neill’s immediate requirements, citing his proven goalscoring ability, physicality, and understanding of the demands placed on a leading forward.

Speaking to RecordSport, Stubbs made it clear just how highly he rates Wilson. He insisted there is no doubt about the striker’s quality and claimed that, if performing at his best, Wilson would stand out as the top striker in Scottish football. For Stubbs, the question is not about ability, but about timing and opportunity.

He also pointed out that Wilson’s recent contract situation at West Ham reduces the risk involved. Having been on a pay-per-play deal that has now ended, Wilson is available without a transfer fee, making a short-term agreement far more appealing. Stubbs argued that offering the striker a six-month contract until the end of the season would not constitute a gamble, but rather a calculated and sensible move.

From Stubbs’ perspective, Wilson fits the type of player O’Neill has historically been able to get the best out of. He suggested that the Celtic manager will already have a clear idea of the profiles he wants in each position and the responsibilities he expects them to shoulder. Wilson, with his experience and self-belief in front of goal, aligns closely with those expectations.

Stubbs also questioned whether now is the right moment for Celtic to strictly adhere to their usual recruitment model. While the club has enjoyed success by signing younger players with resale value, he believes the current situation demands a different approach. With the season finely balanced, Stubbs feels Celtic need players who have been tested at the highest level and can handle pressure without needing time to adapt.

In his view, this is not the moment to take chances on potential. Instead, Celtic should prioritise certainty, reliability, and leadership, especially in attacking areas where matches can be decided by a single moment of quality. Wilson’s career, built on scoring goals in demanding environments, makes him a compelling option in that regard.

Celtic’s broader recruitment strategy has long been admired for its sustainability, but circumstances have shifted. With confidence fragile and the margin for error shrinking, the balance between long-term planning and short-term necessity has tilted. Experience, once seen as a luxury, is now being viewed as an essential ingredient.

O’Neill’s own track record supports this line of thinking. His most successful Celtic sides often relied on seasoned forwards who understood responsibility, thrived under scrutiny, and could deliver when stakes were highest. He has rarely shied away from placing trust in players with the mental strength to lead the line and carry expectation.

The discussion around Wilson also highlights the contrast between him and Kyogo Furuhashi. Kyogo offers familiarity, movement, and an emotional connection with supporters, while Wilson represents a more pragmatic solution shaped by availability and timing. One embodies continuity, the other certainty.

As the transfer window progresses, Celtic may ultimately decide that addressing their attacking issues requires more than one solution. Bringing in different types of forwards to meet different tactical needs remains a possibility. What is beyond doubt, however, is that patience is wearing thin.

With crucial months ahead and little room for missteps, the focus inside the club is firmly fixed on results. Whether through Wilson, Kyogo, or another option entirely, Celtic know they must act quickly and decisively if they are to maintain momentum and meet expectations during a pivotal phase of the season.