Michael Carrick criticised for Middlesbrough FC decision involving Derby County FC

Middlesbrough supporters remain puzzled by a particular transfer call made by Michael Carrick during his time in charge, with many continuing to question the logic behind a move that involved Derby County.

Looking back at Carrick’s spell on Teesside, it was a period that initially promised a great deal but ultimately failed to deliver the club’s main ambition of reaching the Premier League. When Carrick arrived in October 2022, Middlesbrough were in a difficult position, sitting near the bottom of the Championship table in 21st place and facing a potential relegation battle.

Under his leadership, however, the team experienced a remarkable turnaround. In his first season, Carrick guided Boro to a fourth-place finish, a significant achievement that raised hopes of promotion and suggested that the club was heading in the right direction.

Despite that encouraging start, the momentum could not be maintained. Middlesbrough fell short of a top-six finish in each of the following two seasons, and as a result, Carrick was dismissed from his role in June 2025.

January transfer decision draws scrutiny

One decision in particular has continued to attract criticism from supporters. The move, which took place in January of that same year, is now widely viewed by many fans as a major misstep.

The decision centred on defender Matt Clarke, who was allowed to leave Middlesbrough and join Derby County on loan. The arrangement effectively included the possibility of a permanent transfer, although the exact fee involved was not disclosed and is believed to have been relatively low.

At the time, Carrick defended the move, stating that it was beneficial for all parties. He explained that Clarke was eager to secure regular playing time and that the club respected his wishes. Carrick also spoke positively about the defender’s professionalism, highlighting his commitment and consistency in training after returning from a lengthy injury layoff.

Clarke’s impact at Derby County

After making the switch to Pride Park, Clarke quickly became an important figure for Derby County. The move marked his third spell with the club, following two earlier loan stints from Brighton earlier in his career.

During the closing stages of the 2024/25 campaign, Clarke played a vital role in helping Derby maintain their position in the division. He featured in 15 of the club’s final 17 matches, demonstrating his reliability and defensive strength. This contrasted with his time at Middlesbrough earlier in the season, where he had made 14 appearances before departing.

Clarke’s performances continued to impress in the following season. The 29-year-old delivered a series of strong displays that earned him significant recognition at the club’s end-of-season awards ceremony.

He became only the fourth player in Derby’s history to win the Jack Stamps Player of the Season award on two occasions. In addition to that honour, he was also named Players’ Player of the Season, underlining the high regard in which he is held by his teammates.

Fans question Carrick’s judgement

Clarke’s success at Derby has intensified the debate among Middlesbrough fans, many of whom now view the decision to let him go as a costly error. Social media reactions have been particularly strong, with supporters expressing disbelief at what they see as a flawed judgement.

Following Derby’s announcement of Clarke’s awards, numerous Boro fans responded by criticising Carrick’s handling of the situation. One widely shared comment claimed that the former manager had “lost the plot” during his final season in charge.

Another supporter pointed to the decision to move Clarke on in favour of George Edmundson, suggesting that the change had not worked out as intended. The comparison between the two players has become a focal point of the criticism.

This season’s statistics have only added to the frustration. Edmundson has started just three league games for Middlesbrough, while Clarke has been a regular presence for Derby, making 44 appearances across the campaign, excluding the final day.

Mixed reactions from both sets of fans

While Middlesbrough supporters have expressed frustration, some have also acknowledged Clarke’s achievements and praised his performances. One fan congratulated him on his success while questioning the decision to let him leave, describing him as both a top-quality defender and a respected individual.

From Derby’s perspective, the transfer has been viewed as an excellent piece of business. Supporters of the club have been quick to highlight Clarke’s importance, with one fan describing him as one of their best signings in the past decade.

A decision that continues to resonate

Although Clarke’s departure from Middlesbrough was not marked by any controversy at the time, the long-term impact of the move has become increasingly apparent. Many fans believe that if Carrick had not chosen to move him out of the squad, the defender would likely have remained at the club.

The decision to effectively replace Clarke with Edmundson has come under particular scrutiny, especially given how differently their respective seasons have unfolded. For some supporters, it serves as a clear example of a misjudgement that contributed to the team’s struggles.

Reflecting on Carrick’s tenure

Carrick’s time at Middlesbrough will likely be remembered as a mixture of early promise and eventual disappointment. His ability to transform the team in his first season demonstrated his managerial potential, but the failure to sustain that progress ultimately led to his departure.

The debate surrounding Clarke’s transfer highlights the fine margins that often define success and failure in football. Decisions that may seem logical at the time can take on a different significance in hindsight, particularly when outcomes do not align with expectations.

For Middlesbrough fans, the question of whether Carrick made the right call will likely remain a topic of discussion. As Clarke continues to thrive at Derby County, the sense that an opportunity was missed only grows stronger, reinforcing the belief among many that the decision was one that ultimately backfired.

Sergej Jakirovic forced to miss Hull City AFC lap of appreciation due to suspension

As Hull City’s players and coaching staff took part in their traditional end-of-season lap of appreciation in front of supporters, one key figure was notably absent. Manager Sergej Jakirovic was unable to join the celebrations on the pitch and instead had to watch from the stands at the MKM Stadium.

The reason for his absence stemmed from a touchline ban that ruled him out of his side’s crucial final-day clash against Norwich City FC. The fixture carried significant importance, with Hull needing a victory to keep their hopes of reaching the play-offs alive.

Jakirovic had to place all his faith in Hull’s coaching staffCredit: Phil Oldham/Shutterstock

Jakirovic’s suspension was handed down after he was sent off during the Tigers’ 2-2 draw with Leicester City FC on April 21. His dismissal came following an incident involving referee Thomas Kirk, who interpreted the manager’s actions as sarcastic applause directed at one of his decisions.

However, Jakirovic later insisted that his clapping gesture had been misunderstood, claiming that it was intended as encouragement for his players rather than a show of dissent towards the official.

Ban confirmed after FA discussions

Following talks with the The Football Association, it was agreed that Jakirovic would serve a one-match suspension. That ban was applied to Hull’s final Championship fixture of the season against Norwich, meaning he was unable to take his place in the dugout.

In his absence, responsibility for managing the team on the touchline fell to assistant head coach Dean Holden. The coaching setup had to be adjusted further, with other staff members stepping into new roles to ensure the team remained organised during such a high-pressure encounter.

Despite the changes, Hull were still able to deliver when it mattered most. However, the impact of Jakirovic’s suspension extended beyond the match itself, affecting his involvement in post-game activities as well.

Unusual rule keeps manager off the pitch

A particularly frustrating aspect of the ban for Jakirovic was a rule that prevented him from returning to the pitch for a period of two hours after the match had concluded. This meant that even after the final whistle, he was not permitted to join his players and staff for the customary lap of appreciation.

As a result, while the rest of the team acknowledged the supporters from the pitch, Jakirovic remained in the director’s box, observing events from a distance rather than being directly involved.

The situation created a strange contrast, with the manager effectively separated from the celebrations despite the significance of the occasion. For someone used to being at the heart of the action, it was an unusual and challenging experience.

High drama on the final day

The stakes surrounding the match only added to the tension of Jakirovic’s enforced absence. Hull entered the final round of EFL Championship fixtures knowing that victory alone might not be enough—they also needed results elsewhere to go their way.

Jakirovic had a much more glamorous setting to watch Hull’s game against NorwichCredit: Shutterstock Editorial

At kick-off, the Tigers were sitting seventh in the table with 70 points, just outside the play-off positions. Their situation became even more precarious early on when Derby County FC, who were also chasing a top-six finish, scored within the opening five minutes of their match against Sheffield United FC.

Hull’s own game then took a negative turn in the 26th minute when Norwich striker Mohamed Toure put the visitors ahead. At that point, Hull’s play-off ambitions were hanging by a thread.

However, the team responded impressively. Oli McBurnie equalised from the penalty spot shortly afterwards, restoring hope among the home supporters. He then struck again in the 67th minute, scoring what would ultimately prove to be the winning goal.

Elsewhere, results also began to shift in Hull’s favour. Middlesbrough FC played out a 2-2 draw with Wrexham AFC, a result that allowed Hull to climb into sixth place and secure a play-off spot.

From his vantage point in the director’s box, Jakirovic was able to monitor these developments, keeping track of how other matches were unfolding while watching his own team’s progress.

Manager praises staff for stepping up

After the match, Jakirovic acknowledged how difficult it had been not to be on the touchline during such a critical fixture. He admitted that being removed from his usual position was challenging, particularly given the importance of the occasion.

Nevertheless, he expressed confidence in his coaching team and praised the work they had done in his absence. He highlighted the contributions of Dean Holden, as well as other staff members including Marko Salatovic, Andelo Roguljic, and Erbil Bozkurt, noting that they had performed admirably under pressure.

Jakirovic explained that adjustments had to be made quickly once it became clear that multiple staff members would not be available on the bench. Despite these disruptions, the team managed to stay organised and deliver a result that kept their season alive.

Frustration over post-match restrictions

While the victory and qualification for the play-offs provided a positive outcome, Jakirovic did not hide his frustration with the rules that prevented him from joining the post-match celebrations on the pitch.

He described the regulation requiring him to wait two hours before returning to the field as “unbelievable,” suggesting that it is something that should be reconsidered in the future. From his perspective, being unable to share the moment with his players and supporters detracted from what should have been a collective celebration.

McBurnie’s double took his season tally to 17Credit: Getty

Even so, he maintained a sense of perspective, acknowledging that the most important thing was the result. Hull’s success in securing a play-off place ultimately softened the disappointment of his enforced absence.

Focus shifts to play-off challenge

With the final-day drama behind them, Hull now turn their attention to the next stage of the competition. Jakirovic will be back on the touchline for the first leg of their Championship play-off semi-final against Millwall FC, who finished third in the table.

That match, scheduled to take place on May 8 or 9, will mark a return to normality for the manager after his suspension. It also represents the beginning of a new challenge, as Hull aim to complete their journey to promotion.

Having overcome the obstacles of the final day, including the absence of their manager from the sidelines, the Tigers will head into the play-offs with renewed confidence. For Jakirovic, the experience of watching from afar may have been frustrating, but it ultimately ended with the reward of keeping their promotion hopes alive.