Connect with us

Blog

What should Scotland do about a frustrated Ben Doak?

Published

on

Scotland are facing growing questions about how best to use Ben Gannon-Doak, with concerns that the winger’s attacking strengths are being restricted by his new role under head coach Sebastien Pocognoli.

Two years ago, the young forward announced himself to the Tartan Army during Scotland’s Nations League victory over Croatia at Hampden. That November evening was widely viewed as the beginning of his international breakthrough. Gannon-Doak, then a teenager, gave Manchester City defender Josko Gvardiol a difficult night, taking on the highly rated Croatian and exciting supporters with his pace, confidence and direct running.

His reputation arguably reached another high point when he impressed during Scotland’s opening World Cup victory over Haiti. However, frustration has begun to grow, with many supporters feeling that the Bournemouth player is not being used in a way that brings out his best qualities.

Is Scotland’s system limiting Ben Gannon-Doak’s threat?

A Winger Asked to Play at Wing-Back

Gannon-Doak turned 21 on Wednesday, but under Pocognoli he has been deployed as a right wing-back.

Pocognoli appears committed to his preferred system, which does not include traditional wingers. That has created a problem for a player whose biggest strengths are speed, directness and the ability to take defenders on. The concern is that Scotland are limiting one of their most exciting attacking options by asking him to perform a role that demands different qualities.

They face the leaders of Nations League Group B1 and need a victory to retain any possibility of reaching a promotion play-off place.

Pocognoli has addressed the debate, making clear that he is not worried about Gannon-Doak’s position or the criticism surrounding his performances.

The debate has also raised a wider question about whether Scotland should adapt their shape to suit their strongest individual attackers, rather than asking those players to fit a rigid structure. Gannon-Doak’s ability to accelerate past defenders is an option, when opponents are organised and space is limited. If he is positioned too deep, he may receive the ball further from goal and have fewer chances to influence areas. Yet playing him higher could leave Scotland needing another solution to protect the right side defensively.

Not one for Gannon-Doak’s show reel.

Foster Believes the Role Could Frustrate Him

Former Rangers full-back Richard Foster believes asking a winger to operate as a wing-back can be difficult. Speaking on BBC Scotland’s Sportsound, he explained that a natural defender may enjoy moving higher up the pitch when given a wing-back role.

For an established winger, however, being required to retreat and defend can feel restrictive. Foster suggested that Gannon-Doak could be frustrated by having to spend so much time fulfilling defensive responsibilities rather than concentrating on attacking.

He pointed to Findlay Curtis, Josh McPake and Gannon-Doak as three of the squad’s most exciting players, yet felt the system prevented them from being used together effectively. Against North Macedonia, two of those players were not brought on.

He recalled the impact McPake and Curtis had made when introduced against Slovenia, where their willingness to take opponents on lifted the team. Foster argued that supporters want to be entertained and see Scotland’s most exciting talents on the pitch.

In his view, the formation needs to change if those players are to have a greater influence.

Brown Says Scotland Are Not Getting the Best From Him

Former Scotland captain Scott Brown also believes Gannon-Doak is not being used to his full potential. Brown said the youngster had been required to make several last-ditch defensive headers during the recent match, while also having to learn responsibilities such as defending one-on-one and taking throw-ins.

Brown’s comments underline the argument that Scotland may be asking Gannon-Doak to concentrate on areas that do not make the best use of his natural ability.

Final Product Remains a Concern

Although his role has become a fresh talking point, Gannon-Doak’s end product has been questioned for some time. His passing, decision-making and finishing have not always matched the quality of his build-up play.

That was evident in the match against North Macedonia. Gannon-Doak made an excellent run towards the byline and won the penalty that proved decisive in the 2-1 victory. However, Brown felt he could have taken his shot earlier instead of adding another touch.

When Gannon-Doak first broke into the Scotland side in 2024, supporters were prepared to overlook moments when he failed to find a teammate or made the wrong decision in important situations. As his international appearances increase, expectations have risen and those weaknesses are attracting more attention.

The challenge is therefore not only about finding the right position for him. He must also improve the quality of his final pass, shooting and decision-making if he is to become a more complete attacking threat.

Pocognoli Remains Satisfied

Despite the criticism, Pocognoli has publicly backed the player’s performances. He said he was happy as long as Gannon-Doak remained high up the pitch and continued creating one-on-one situations.

The Scotland head coach acknowledged that the youngster is still developing and needs to work on specific aspects of his game, particularly his end product. However, he pointed to the penalty-winning run against North Macedonia and the opportunities created in matches against Slovenia as evidence of his contribution.

Pocognoli believes Gannon-Doak is most effective when Scotland control possession, dominate matches and put him in positions where he can attack defenders.

The wider debate, though, is unlikely to disappear. Scotland have an exciting young winger, but supporters and former players want to see him given the freedom to use his attacking qualities. The trip to Switzerland will provide another opportunity to assess whether Pocognoli’s approach is working.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending